Look, Ma! I’m straddling a fence on a slippery slope!
Posted by Ethan Barron on Friday, January 22nd, 2010
I won’t lie, I’m not 100% ready to weigh in on the Castor Semenya issue yet. There’s a lot going on here and I will admit that I don’t have all the relevant information. If you want some of the latest updates, you can read this article at NYtimes.com. To be honest, it actually scares me more than anything else. And by that I mean it scares me anytime politics and genetics or politics and the human body get put in the same room. The fight always gets ugly when that happens.
At first glance, I don’t feel that this is an issue of fairness. If someone is born with a genetic disorder/advantage then that’s just athletics. (I really dislike the use of the word defect or disorder in this situation too) In a lot of ways, Shaq has a disorder…he’s freakishly tall and weighs about 330 lbs. And yes, it would be unfair if I played a game of 1-on-1 with Shaq. But that doesn’t mean that he should be penalized because of that. And that’s really what we’re talking about here…people that Castor is beating are upset about that.
In my eyes, sport is simple. It’s about taking your innate gifts and making the most of them. If someone’s better than you because they were born with an advantage…tough noogies. But if someone artificially boosts the gifts they were born with, then that’s a different story.
It looks like Semenya may have been born with a physiology that gave her an elevated testosterone level. If so, right now, I’m pretty sure that I don’t have a problem with that. Floyd Landis having 12x his innate testosterone levels in the Tour de France – problem. Tayshaun Prince (6′ 9″) having a 7′ 2″ wing span and being a great defender – not a problem. Ethan Hawke surgically making himself 2″ taller in Gattaca – problem. Babe Ruth having some extra weight to hit home runs because of all the beer and hot dogs (and horrible pitching) – not a problem. Mark McGwire and Barry Bonds becoming pharmaceutical petri dishes to break records – problem.
Off the top of my head, a couple of my concerns with all this are:
#1 – The athlete’s health – Too many athletes, coaches, agents, etc put health on the shelf for the betterment of performance. Is your lineman at risk for diabetes? How many concussions does your safety have? How hard is Shaq’s heart beating to circulate his blood? Will that creatine give you pancreatic cancer? What is Castor’s testosterone doing to her body long term? Stuff like that.
#2 – Who actually wants a level playing field? – If we medically or pharmaceutically level the playing field then aren’t we just destroying the powerhouse/underdog aspect of sport. David v. Goliath epitomizes sport. David isn’t too impressive if someone made Goliath take some pills to make him the same size as David.
I’m actually pretty interested to hear what you all think. We had a great back and forth about race, genetics, and sport last year. Maybe we should get one going about gender, genetics, and sport. Any thoughts out there? If you’d like to respond with more than a ‘comment’ then feel free to email me a post.
Filed in Uncategorized | 3 responses so far


